“Society doesn’t need newspapers. What we need is journalism.”

The extremely smart and usually right Clay Shirky breaks down the newspaper problem for you. Hint: Unless they realize what business they’re actually in — which is to say, not selling paper — they’ll die. The digital world has brought changes that are unavoidably destructive to the old way of doing business as a newspaper, which depended on it being hard to duplicate and distribute information. There’s no way to undo that, and there’s absolutely no sane reason to want to.

But, as recent events have shown, no newspaper firm yet understands this, and so they continue to fail, fail again, and fail some more, all the while refusing to alter their business plans — and while this is happening, good people are being put out of work as a direct result of the failure of management vision.

Remember, the railroads weren’t broken by the automobile. They were broken by the mistaken belief they were in the railroad business. What their customers wanted was transportation; how the package moves from St Louis to Denver is completely irrelevant to the customer.

One thought on ““Society doesn’t need newspapers. What we need is journalism.”

  1. You’re right–it’s ridiculous. Our local paper has become a shell of the second-rate paper it used to be, in the quest for a 20% profit margin (which is their goal, and which, say, a retailer would totally drool over). So where will the news come from? Particularly the local news. I am a complete news junkie, and now that the local paper won’t scratch the itch, I have to just go to the NY Times and NPR. Charlotte may have the shittiest paper in the world, but we’re lucky to have one of the very best NPR stations (much better than, say, Atlanta), so I do get my fix.